Sunrise on the Reaping (2026) Review: Haymitch's Games — Critics Land at 70% on Rotten Tomatoes, Calling It a Thin Slog or a Franchise High
Francis Lawrence's second prequel sends a young Haymitch Abernathy into the 50th Hunger Games, and critics cannot agree on whether the series needed it.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping arrives in theaters and IMAX on November 20, 2026, and the first wave of reviews describes a franchise film that splits critics down the middle. At the embargo lift on November 17 it sat at about 70% on Rotten Tomatoes from roughly 60 reviews, and at 56 on Metacritic, which is the site's 'mixed or average' band. That ties it with both Mockingjay films as the second-lowest-rated entry in the series, well behind The Hunger Games (85%) and Catching Fire (90%).
What the movie is about
Francis Lawrence, who directed four of the earlier films, returns for a story set 24 years before the original. It follows 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada, at the reaping for the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, an edition that doubles the number of tributes taken from every district. Haymitch is pulled from his family in District 12 and shipped to the Capitol with three other District 12 tributes, and he soon understands he has been set up to fail. The screenplay is by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie.
The ensemble is large even by this series' standards: Ralph Fiennes, Elle Fanning, Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, Maya Hawke, Glenn Close, Mckenna Grace, Whitney Peak, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Lili Taylor and Billy Porter are all in the credits. Culkin plays Caesar Flickerman and Fanning plays Effie Trinket, the kind of Capitol faces that give a prequel its pleasure of recognition.
Where critics split
The most generous reviews treat the film as a high point. The Wrap calls it the series' most effective balance of crowd-pleasing spectacle and sobering commentary, SciFiNow argues it is one of the franchise's crowning achievements, and Polygon calls it the most depressing entry and one of the best. Variety's Owen Gleiberman is more guarded: he finds it 'meandering and more than a bit thin' but still gives it a fresh rating and credits the direction.
The negative reviews are harsher. IndieWire calls it 'a dreary slog.' The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw gave it one star and called it 'surreally boring,' arguing it has no real reason to exist beyond mining a fanbase. Deadline's complaint is structural: the franchise has reached a point where 'any significant death is obviously just an unfortunate accident,' because we already know who survives. GamesRadar+ lands in the middle, saying the script strains to connect to the earlier films but works as a standalone.
The prequel problem
That last complaint is the one that matters most. Haymitch's fate is known to anyone who has seen the original films, so the tension has to come from how the film handles the games rather than who survives them. Whether that is enough is exactly where the reviews divide. The Times, notably, sides with Haymitch's own on-screen line that there should never be another Hunger Games, a pointed way to say the story's moral has been made many times over.
Our take
On the evidence of the reviews, the film is a polarizing but watchable entry whose strongest case rests on its cast and its bleak tone, and whose weakest is a 158-minute runtime and a predetermined outcome. We give it a FilmRated score of 64, in line with the critical middle. Fans of the books and the earlier prequel will likely get the most out of it; viewers hoping for a surprise should keep expectations measured. The film opens on Friday, and the opening-weekend number, which one projection puts around $120 million domestically, will show how much the mixed notices matter.
Scores as of November 19, 2026; Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic figures may move as more reviews arrive. Watch the official trailer above and see our earlier release-date preview for cast and plot background.
Related movies
Related articles
- The Hunger Games Returns to Haymitch's Own Reaping in Sunrise on the Reaping, Out November 20
- New Movies Coming Out in November 2026: Release Dates — Godzilla, Dr. Seuss, a new Hunger Games, Disney's Hexed and the Fockers all land in one month.
- I Play Rocky (2026) Review: Ippolito's Stallone — Farrelly's Stallone Biopic Earns 88% on RT, and Critics Agree the Lead Is a Knockout
- Sunrise on the Reaping Opens to $110M+ — Fourth-Best Hunger Games Debut Ever, a 147% Jump Over Songbirds & Snakes