Ebenezer (2026) Review: Depp's Scrooge Splits Critics — Critics Call It Passionless at 53% on Rotten Tomatoes, But Audiences Give It an A- CinemaScore
Ti West's horror-tinged take on A Christmas Carol splits critics and audiences, with Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, and Sam Claflin surrounding a restrained Johnny Depp performance.

Paramount's "Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol" opened wide on November 13, 2026, with Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, and Sam Claflin rounding out the cast under director Ti West — the horror filmmaker's first mainstream studio feature after "X" and "Pearl." At 116 minutes and rated PG-13 for frightening material, it's one of at least five English-language screen versions of Dickens's novella released since 1999, and arrives as the highest-profile Depp vehicle since his 2022 defamation trial made headlines.
The reception has been chilly rather than hostile. Rotten Tomatoes has the film at 53% as of this writing, Metacritic's weighted critic average sits at 46, and the Hollywood Reporter's own review roundup summed up the mood bluntly: a comeback vehicle for Depp met with a lukewarm response rather than the outright drubbing some expected, or the enthusiastic reclamation his fans hoped for.
SlashFilm's review put it plainly: Depp's Scrooge "neither helps nor hurts" the film, describing it as a largely passionless retelling. The surprise, per that review, is restraint — Depp is going for "respectable prestige" rather than the scenery-chewing outrageousness his take on the role might have suggested, landing as solid but unremarkable rather than embarrassing.
RogerEbert.com's review (published under the site's house byline) credited West with proving he can direct outside straight horror, even while finding Depp's Scrooge overtheatrical in the film's first half. Its sharpest praise was reserved for the back stretch, where Depp finally lets some real vulnerability show through — a late-film turn the review called the difference between the film working and not.
Other outlets were less forgiving. ScreenDaily called the film's Scrooge "cartoonish" and the whole project "underwhelming" and "unnecessary" given how many prior adaptations already exist, while TheWrap's review argued Depp's schtick has gone stale and that the production leans on familiar Dickens beats rather than finding a real reason to retell the story now.
Where reviews agreed more than they disagreed was on the supporting cast and craft. McKellen, Grint, and Claflin were repeatedly singled out as the more grounded, effective presences on screen, and West's eye for period atmosphere and horror-adjacent staging of the ghost sequences drew consistent, if secondary, praise even from reviews cool on Depp's lead performance.
Audiences have responded noticeably warmer than critics. The film's CinemaScore came in at A-, and its IMDb rating sits at 7.2 from several thousand votes as of this writing — a gap between critical and audience reception wide enough that it's become part of the story around the film's rollout, alongside renewed scrutiny of Depp's first major studio lead role since 2022.
Taken together, "Ebenezer" lands as a technically competent, cast-elevated adaptation that most critics found safe rather than essential, anchored by a Depp performance reviewers describe as a measured comeback rather than a triumphant one. For anyone curious about Depp's post-2022 studio return or Ti West's range outside horror, it's worth a look; for a definitive "A Christmas Carol," most of the reviews above suggest looking elsewhere first.
Related movies
Related articles
- Best Comedy Movies of 2026 So Far, Ranked: Top 6 — A Cannes Breakout Beats Pixar, a Shelved Coyote Movie and a McDonagh Farce
- Godzilla Minus Zero Box Office: $30.6M Opening Tops Chart — Toho's Subtitled Kaiju Sequel Nearly Triples Minus One and Beats The Cat in the Hat
- I Play Rocky (2026) Review: Ippolito's Stallone — Farrelly's Stallone Biopic Earns 88% on RT, and Critics Agree the Lead Is a Knockout
- Josephine (2026) Review: De Araújo's Sundance Winner — Critics Land at 96% on Rotten Tomatoes and 85 on Metacritic for a Trauma Drama Built From the Director's Own Life